So, I'm writing a paper on Catholic
Just War Theory and it's relationship to the war in Kosovo/the Balkans during the Clinton administration. I chose that conflict specifically, because I figure that everyone in the class will choose the current war in Iraq, and because while I want the war to end, and I hate Bush as much as anyone, I dislike the common view that's very much "This is all the Republicans' fault, and bush is the most evil president since Nixon, since he got us into a war." The democrats are not heroes, people.
But, that's not the revisionist history I came here to talk to you about.
While doing my research, I came across this quote:
The desire to avoid war is a fundamental idea in the Christian view of politics, just as the romanticization of war is a pagan one that reflects a disregard for the sanctity of life.Tell the first part of that sentence to our current administration. As I've stated, Bush isn't unique in going to war, but I'm fairly sure that his constant invoking the power of God is not usual. Presidents usually talk about democracy, freedom, and justice when they want to justify war. It's propaganda meant to tug at your heartstrings, but it's secular.
Also, tell it to Emperor Constantine, who converted to Christianity specifically to gain victory in battle. Tell it to Pope Urban I, who called on his followers to go "retake the holy land" (kill Muslims), and so started the first crusade. Unfortunately, his speech was among the most convincing in history, because a mass of peasants did go out and try to "retake the holy land." Along the way, they slaughtered a lot of Jews, until they finally reached Jerusalem... and were promptly all killed by the Muslims, because the Muslims had an army, and the peasants were... you know, peasants and sightly lacking in military training.
And you know I have a warped, morbid sense of humor, because I envision this last battle as a kind of Eddie Izzard-esque farce. (I'm also adding in Eddie Izzard's voice, which automatically makes it funny.)
Muslim One: What the hell is up with these guys?
Muslim Two: Some Christians. They're revolting.
Muslim One: I'm not going to make the obvious joke. What are they armed with?
Muslim Two: Well, they've got some shovels.
Muslim One: Shovels?
Muslim Two: A few of them might have pitchforks.
Muslim One: That's not going to be much of fair fight.
Muslim Two: I don't know. You don't want to know what they did to the Jews along the way.
Muslim One: ...We can't make that funny.
Muslim Two: Better end the skit, then.
And that's how it happened.
As for the second part: "just as the romanticization of war is a pagan one that reflects a disregard for the sanctity of life," well, that's just insulting.
EDIT: Another quote!
Just war doctrine wasn’t so widely ignored at one point in U.S. history. During the Civil War, Tom Woods of Columbia University has pointed out, Catholic newspapers in the North-at the direction of the bishops-editorialized on behalf of the South, the region that fought with a just cause in mind, first for the principle of subsidiarity, and to protect homes and property from invading Union troops. Slavery has long been discouraged by Catholic teaching, but Just War doctrine could not be violated to abolish it.
That is, the greater evil-war-could not be used to end a lesser evil. Slavery should have been discontinued, as is was in all other countries except Haiti, by peaceful meansThe words, they fail me. I don't see how fighting for the right to own human being can be thought of as just cause. And who is this guy to decide that slavery is the "lesser evil"?